Are there any other Content Mills like Textbroker?
Content mills have been labelled by many writing critics as the sub-basement of the writing world.
Low pay, unreasonable clients, and low skilled writers are three of the more common complaints about content mill websites.
But despite the critics, content mill writing has been an acceptable way for many non-professional writers to make some extra money by pursuing their interest in writing.
You likely won’t retire doing content mill writing, but with a basic writing skill level you can explore a path to gradually making more money over time.
Many people are familiar with Textbroker.com because it is one of the longest running content mills that have provided writers with the opportunity to make a few bucks along the way.
Here are 5 alternatives to Textbroker for you to consider to start you on the path to writing riches! (sort of).
Note: A couple of these mentioned aren’t actually content mills, but are freelancing platforms — nevertheless, these are good alternatives to consider, which could lead to higher pay and long-term working relationships with clients.
Useful Posts:
Hirewriters:
Hirewriters has a number of unique features about it – some good, some bad.
On the good side is that you can line up jobs and get to them according to your schedule.
With Textbroker; you take a job, then have to complete it before taking another job.
Hirewriters lets you keep your writing queue full and this means that you don’t lose out on potential jobs just because you’re in the middle of another.
Another perk is clients can pay you bonuses if they really like your work, up to $20.
On the downside there is a penalty assessed if you miss a job deadline.
Miss too many deadlines and you will find your skill level taking a hit.
From one perspective, it is what entry level writers expect from a content mill: do the work, on time, with an acceptable level of quality, and you will get paid for your efforts.
If you’re keen on a Textbroker alternative, this is a decent option to check out.
Upwork
This isn’t a content mill, it’s a freelancing website – but somewhere you can still be paid for your writing.
For those new to the online writing industry, Upwork is the merger of two former content mill competitors: Elance and oDesk.
Both had solid reputations in the industry, but it may speak volumes about how things really work when competitors merge.
While this isn’t a “content mill,” in the typical sense, again it is a place where many people hope to pay a small amount for written work.
It has one of the better reputations with those that do work with content mills and there is the opportunity to meet new clients and go for higher paying gigs in time.
On this platform, writers usually bid for available jobs, and clients base their decision on the offered price and the resume of the writer.
This can make it difficult for new writers to get a foothold, so patience is required.
Still, Upwork is one of the most popular websites for new writers and some writers do manage to demand decent pay for their efforts.
As a Freelancer, it shouldn’t be overlooked.
If you have a solid profile set up, you can also get clients approach you for work directly.
iWriter
iWriter has a pretty negative reputation from writers themselves and the quality that is produced has been criticised by many.
On the writer end of things, it functions like most content mills, where clients post their jobs and asking price and writers have at it.
One of the important differences with iWriter is clients can, and often do, ask for one hour turnaround time.
So if you compare it to say Hirewriters, you can forget about scheduling your own writing assignments.
It’s like fast food takeout through the drive through window.
A lot of clients seem to complain about the quality of the writers, so if you are a competent writer – you could be favorited and then be asked for personally and build up a client base.
A great difficulty that many people find with iwriter, is getting your first jobs.
As you start off at an entry level and there can be a limited amount available at this stage.
You can pay to do a course at iwriter that will propel you to a higher level, where more jobs will be available.
However, that course currently costs $199 and with the low pay, it would take you a long time to recuperate that investment.
Fiverr:
Again, Fiverr like Upwork is not a content mill – it’s a freelancing platform.
Fiverr is a great platform, but the quality of writing you can find here is often not good.
If you’re a good writer, you may be able to charge more of a premium and do well.
Fiverr is an online freelancing platform and so, it’s really a *content mill,* in the usual sense.
However, it’s similar in the small amount you can get paid just starting out.
The potential client with a content mill sets the price, and it doesn’t take into account any research or rewrites you may have to do.
(More on the general issue of rewrites later.)
But with Fiverr, the idea is to offer writing, (and many other services) for a small price, which is technically what a content mill does as well.
The difference is, as you progress at Fiverr, you have the ability to add “gig extras,” and charge much more.
There is a lot of competition on Fiverr these days, especially for things like Freelance writing. So, you’d have to make an effort to really stand out.
It’s been said that people who have a video of themselves discussing their particular service, have a far greater chance of success.
So, if you aren’t camera shy – this would be a very good idea.
You also have the ability to charge different prices depending on things such as, the length of the article.
So, you could charge $5 for just 300 words and then people would need to purchase additional gigs for more.
You will need to price your skills competitively at first though, as Fiverr is very much dependent on customer reviews.
You will want to get some good reviews at first and build your reputation from there.
Joining Fiverr is completely free and, unlike content mills, you don’t need to complete any tests to get started.
Writer Access
One of the unique features of WriterAccess is when you go to their home page you find a series of downloadable e-books giving advice to clients about what they need to get the best deal.
This is actually just covert advertising, but for clients who are looking for cheap writing there is no reason not to give the freebies a gander.
Writers can get a clue from this, since if a website is telling clients how to get the cheapest price, what does this tell the writer about the price they can expect to get paid?
Who Pays The Most?
OK, this is a question that has neither a simple nor an easy answer.
The best and most honest answer is – it depends.
It depends on the number of times you have to rewrite an article, if at all.
It also has to consider if you can make money above and beyond the base rate, which is usually $.01 per word or less.
Here, the total for writing 500 words at $.01 would be $5.
Yet at the Beginner levels in many content mills you will be getting paid $.003 or three tenths of a cent per word.
That can be downright discouraging.
It’s not unusual for clients to ask for a rewrite or editing your original work, and that will but into your actual pay rate.
For example, if you agree to do a job for $5 and it takes 1 hour, you earn $5.
But if the client requires changes and those changes take you an additional 30 minutes, then you actually make $5 for 90 minutes of work or $3.33 an hour.
Some content mills give every writer a second chance for the client to accept the job via a rewrite.
Others do not, which means you can spend an hour of your time expecting to make $5 and end up with $0 and a grumpy attitude to go along with it.
With freelancing websites, you can set your own fee and so, of course you can make more with those overall.
Is Content Mill Writing For Me?
Practically speaking, it will take months or even years for you to reach a decent level of income from content mills, if you can ever do it.
But it is a good way to try and improve your writing skills, beyond knowing the nuts and bolts of spelling and grammar.
You can get a wide variety of jobs, everything from blogs to content pages for websites to public relations releases to product descriptions that will be found on Amazon and other high traffic websites.
You may not be famous but it is very likely you will find your work out on the web somewhere.
How many people can say that?
Here are a few types of people who are likely to benefit personally and financially from going down to the content mill:
- People who like to write as a hobby
- Those who have been told they are good writers and aren’t doing anything about it.
- English majors.
- People who like expressing their ideas.
- People who casually come up with product reviews or descriptions in their minds
- Crossword puzzle lovers (it’s about the words)
- Poetry writers (yes, there are content mills that ask for poetry content – believe it or not!).
The most direct advice is…. To simply try.
You won’t know until you try, and you can make a little bit of money for trying.
If you find out your writing skills are above the average writer out there, then you can put the pedal to the metal and see how fast and far you can go with your newly discovered talent.
Someone once said to me, “If it were me, I would want to know.”
Ask yourself how you would respond if someone said that to you about writing for content mills or anyone else.
Then you have your answer.
Beyond Content Mills – a side-note from the website owner!
This article was actually outsourced from Hirewriters and I’ve found some high quality writers on this platform.
However, I’ve found the results via content mills very hit and miss I’ve now personally had the greatest success hiring writers on Upwork.
If you would like to earn more online for your talents in the long run, your best bet is building your OWN online business. This is where I got started.
Howard says
An excellent article Nat.
I have often wondered just how lucrative it might be to write as a freelancer. But I can see from this that it is both a competitive and decidedly underpaid way to make some extra money.
I think I may be better off putting that effort back into my own website. What do you think?
Thanks for this,
Howard
Nat says
Hey Howard – sure building your website or blog is a great way to make money in the long term, (as long as you stick with it!). But it can take a long time to start making money from. So, a lot of bloggers/website owners start freelancing as a way to make money in the meantime. In fact, there are plenty of bloggers who exceed their income from freelancing in the end anyway. So, while the content mills aren’t the best place to make money freelancing, it’s a way that some people may feel comfortable getting their feet wet initially and seeing what it is like. Then perhaps they will feel more confident directly making contacts.
Daniel says
Hi Nat,
I really like Fiverr, although I’m not a writer on fiverr, I have made $100 on fiverr in just two months.
It starts slow but after I’ve gained some positive reviews people will start to contact you very often.
Never tried to be a writer but it seems to be a good idea to start.
Nat says
Hey Daniel – good to hear you’ve done well on Fiverr… what service are you providing? Writing gigs on Fiverr are pretty competitive I think. Although, people who have a video on their sales page seem to do well.
Jojo says
After reading your post I sort of became discouraged to take up writing as a way to make money online. Seems to be a lot of work for not a lot of money.
But you did give me one idea. I am often struggling to create content for my site and using content mills might be a great idea to add content to my site without writing myself (just like you did with this post.
I also agree with you that starting your own business is the best way to make money online. It can give you far more revenue for less work.
Thanks for an interesting post.
Nat says
Hey Jojo – it’s not very much money, but it can be a way for writers to get started. Also, I do know plenty of bloggers that end up exceeding their blog income with freelance writing and I guess this way could be a way of trying it out. Some writers can really get content written incredibly quickly, so they can make a decent sum, even with content mills. Yes, I’ve started purchasing writing now and again and I’ve found hirewriters the best so far – for quality. Thanks for taking the time to comment!
Chris says
Hi Nat-
I was surprised at the end of the article to read that it was outsourced from Hirewriters. I thought it was pretty well written!
Was this the “expert” level? If so, it would fall under the 1,000 – 2,000 word count for only $32.40?
Nat says
Hi Chris – actually, the thing with Hirewriters is… even if you ask for an article from a lower level – like general writers, beginner, or skilled – expert writers sometimes pick it up! It was an expert writer than picked up this one to do. So, it’s a bit of a lottery. I have some articles that I’ve purchased from there, but then have had to do quite a bit of editing. This was a good one. I think I paid $14 for this article…
Juliette Cruz says
Hi Nat, some of the information in the article isn’t correct. For example, iwriter allows you to peruse the articles/jobs for hire and the time allotted for an article is transparent before you ever take it. You can schedule your time and there is work for beginning writers. Like anything, you must log in frequently to check for work, but it is there. The most prevalent thing to know about iwriter is of all the content mils mentioned, the pay is perhaps the lowest on this site. Writer Access actually pays quite well but the acceptance and approval process is long and a bit grueling. Getting work can be difficult because it disappears quickly. However, if you log in daily you can pick up work. You must be vigilant, however. Of all the sites you mentioned, Writer Access pays the most… I also wanted to mention that some of the sites you mentioned aren’t content mills, they are websites where you try to solicit clients. Fiverrrr and Upwork are two such sites.
Juliette Cruz says
I’ve written for almost every site you mentioned for quite some time, upwards of three plus years. I just wanted to offer a little clarification for your readers. Your readers should also consider Crowd Content, Copify, and Content Runner.
Nat says
I believe I’ve heard of crowd content – but not the other two you mention. If you’d like to write a brand new update of this article – including the options you recommend, I’d be more than happy. If you’re interested you can contact me here with your rates.. Many thanks Juliette.
Nat says
Hi Juliette – thanks this article is several years old and actually outsourced via hirewriters. However, having read it back again, I’ve realised it wasn’t made that clear that fiverr and upwork aren’t actually content mills and are freelancing platforms – so, I’ve made that more clear now. However, it’s probably best all platforms mentioned actually are content mills in this article and so, I will update this article soon and include alternatives thank you. A long time ago, I tried to go on iwriter as a writer myself to check it out – but I just found there were limited jobs for people just starting out, with zero reviews. Is this not the case anymore? I will take a look at writer Access. Is Writer Access your top recommendation? Thanks for your feedback!